Nov 4 / Kelly Alpert

Seven Misconceptions About EMDR Therapy

Misconceptions About EMDR Therapy I Hear in the Room

Have you ever had a client tell you EMDR therapy won’t work for them before you’ve even finished taking a history? Or caught yourself wondering whether a session stalled because the client “just wasn’t a good fit”?

I hear versions of these beliefs often, from clients and sometimes from colleagues. Most of them come from a narrow picture of EMDR therapy as a trauma protocol rather than a comprehensive psychotherapy. Left unexamined, they shape who gets referred, what gets targeted, and when we decide the work is done.

Here are seven misconceptions I run into most often, and how I think about each one.

1. "You need a specific, conscious traumatic memory."

Our unconscious minds organize experience differently than our conscious minds do. Any aversive experience that holds maladaptive information about the self, others, or the world, along with the emotional confusion that comes with it, is fair game for reprocessing.

This matters most with complex developmental trauma. Often, we aren’t working with a single event at all. We’re working with “a day in the life,” or with the absence of something that should have happened, such as a parent who was emotionally available to their child when they needed it. Children who get that can pretty well regulate their own emotions as adults; children who don't often struggle with emotional regulation as adults.

It’s hard to identify discrete moments in time where a need went unmet and it was remembered that way. It was instead, many moments that were unremarkable and unfortunately familiar. And while these experiences still live in the client’s memory network, they often don’t identify it as a problem. Instead, they show up as the client who appears to be self-sufficient or conversely apologizes for taking up space in session.

So when a client says, “Nothing bad really happened,” I get curious about what didn’t happen.


2. "EMDR therapy will make you feel nothing about the past."

A SUD of zero is not the absence of emotion. It’s a calm body while feeling what any reasonable person would feel about what actually happened. What resolves is the distress of it and the emotional confusion about responsibility, safety, and choice.

Clients sometimes push back: “It can’t be a zero. What happened will always be disturbing.”

When that happens, I ask them to consider whether they are actually in a state of distress, or whether they have understandable feelings about what is true. I offer the example of a physical injury, the difference between recognizing that you were hurt when you broke a bone and still feeling as though the injury is happening now. Reprocessing changes the emotional response in the present-day; it doesn’t change the truth of what actually happened.


3. "No activation in the body means no disturbance."

Sometimes a quiet body is a calm body. Sometimes it’s a body in hypoarousal: disconnected, frozen, or collapsed.

Part of our work is helping clients learn to tell the difference. As the body metabolizes that stored frozenness, collapse, and disconnection, clients often begin to access the fear, anxiety, or panic that was too much for them at the time, so their systems shut down.

That emergence can feel like things are getting worse. Often, it means the opposite. Preparing clients for it can make the difference in whether they stay with the process.


4. "I had a normal childhood, so EMDR therapy isn't for me."

Maybe they did have a good childhood. Maybe that’s what they’ve been told. Or maybe it’s what they needed to tell themselves to get through. More than one of these can be true at the same time.

A client can have had a good enough childhood and still carry adverse experiences that shape how they relate to themselves, others, and the world today. The foundation of EMDR psychotherapy is that the past is alive in the present.

So rather than debating the childhood, I start with the present. What is happening for this client now? What are they doing and not doing, because of what did and didn’t happen earlier in their lives? If they’re struggling in the present, they may be surprised by what comes up from the past.


5. "EMDR therapy is just CBT or DBT with bilateral stimulation."

Many clients loop during reprocessing: checking the facts, listing things they could be doing differently, reaching for gratitude or forgiveness. Those responses can look like progress. In reprocessing, they are often defensive when they emerge before the client has accessed and metabolized the disturbing material.

EMDR therapy is both a top-down and a bottom-up approach. It helps people process cognitively, somatically, emotionally, and existentially. That said, clients will still do in sessions what they do in their lives to manage their experience, making it more of a challenge to allow for the process to unfold organically.

If you suspect a client’s coping strategies are functioning more as a defense, be brave and name it. Help them find the balance: using those strategies to manage between sessions and approaching what they’ve been managing when you process together.

New perspectives are a byproduct of reprocessing, not the antidote to the pain.


6. "Attachment styles are fixed."

Attachment styles develop out of unresolved attachment wounds. When we heal those wounds, attachment can move towards greater security.

This is where Relational EMDR Therapy® is especially useful. It helps clients work through the barriers that keep them from finding, building, and maintaining relationships grounded in mutual respect, honesty, reciprocity, and choice. Often the therapeutic relationship is the first place they get to practice that.

7. "EMDR therapy is completed in 6-12 sessions."

Simple PTSD, or a single presenting issue, may resolve in 6 to 12 reprocessing sessions, or fewer. But the further out someone lives on the trauma continuum, the more complex their presenting issues and defenses tend to be. Treatment takes longer, and the treatment plan evolves over time. Resolving one target memory often brings the next layer into view, revealing what another facet of the issue we’re working on, such as a client who sought treatment for panic attacks may eventually be doing the deeper work of trusting their own perceptions.

That isn’t a shortcoming of the model. It’s about treating our clients holistically. It’s what happens when we treat EMDR therapy as a psychotherapy rather than a tool for symptom relief.


What these misconceptions have in common

Each of these misconceptions view EMDR therapy as a technique: something you apply to the right memory, for the right client, for a set number of sessions.

The longer I practice, the less I find that to be true. EMDR therapy is a way of understanding how the past lives in the present. It asks us to meet the whole person, including the parts that defend, disconnect, or insist everything was fine.

Which of these do you hear most often in your practice? And, if we’re honest, which ones have we held ourselves?

If these misconceptions sound familiar, whether you hear them from clients or recognize them from your own training, you don't have to untangle them alone.
At The Center for Excellence in EMDR Therapy, this is the conversation we keep coming back to: what it means to practice EMDR therapy as a comprehensive psychotherapy, not a protocol.
 
Healing the Wounds of Attachment and Rebuilding Self goes deeper into the developmental and attachment work behind several of the myths above.
The Craft of EMDR Therapy builds the AIP case conceptualization that helps us recognize defenses, hypoarousal, and the longer arc of complex treatment.
And case consultation offers a place to bring the clients who don't fit the textbook.

If you are ready to gain a foundation of EMDR training, explore the Basic Training courses where you can immediately begin to implement this therapy into your own clinical practice. I hope you'll join us.
Explore upcoming trainings here.

About the Author

Kelly Alpert, LCSW-C, is an EMDRIA Certified Therapist and Approved Consultant and the owner of a small group practice in Bethesda, MD.
She specializes in complex developmental and attachment trauma, childhood sexual abuse, and grief and loss, and offers individual and group consultation to newly trained and experienced EMDR therapists.
You can find more information about Kelly here: https://www.pathwaystopeacellc.com/